Review : SKORA Base

• Type : Minimal
• Use : Road running
• Price : $110

Introduction
I became aware of SKORA earlier this year. At a time where many different makers come out with many different proposals, I was intrigued with their design almost as much as with their slogan, “Run Real”. The introduction text on the website sounds much like the book Born to Run and doesn’t include any specifics on how exactly SKORA shoes help you perform or favour what they call “real running”. Fast forward a couple months and a pair of their Base model landed on my desk.


First impression
Right out of the box, the shoe features a couple elements that attract the eye. The overall design is close to what now seems to become a standard in minimal shoes – slightly curved inward, flat interior with a removable insole and wide toe box. It uses an x-shaped Velcro system on the top, but also a heel strap that reminded me of the Vibram FiveFingers or the Saucony Hattori. The fabric around the foot is very soft and feels like a thermal sweater, which made me think this shoe was designed for a barefoot wear. Last but not least, the sole has a bizarre double-rectangle pattern on the front, and a somewhat elevated shape at the heel. The Base is not a super lightweight either, at 7.9oz, which came as a surprise.

The purported use for the shoe, according to the web site, is road, gym and triathlon. How a triathlon differs from road use, I couldn’t say. Also kind of surprising to me is the overall height of the shoe, at 13mm including the insole, which is sensibly higher than, say, an EVO II from Vivo (5mm) or a Road Glove from Merrell (4mm).


Field test
I wore the Base for a couple short runs (5-6km), at first wearing socks. I took the insole out right away to make the shoe as minimal and as low as possible. It felt heavier than the other barefoot-type shoes I use regularly, but performed like any other should. However, I have to say that even on short distances, my proprioception was hindered by the sole design, which feels thick and unresponsive. I could feel the rectangle patterns in the front and the shape at the heel and it bugged me a little bit, mostly because I couldn’t figure out what advantage they bring.

Then I went for a longer run. Past the 10k mark, the weight of the Base became more noticeable and I started to wish I could tighten up the shoe way more. The x-shaped Velcro strap is approximate at best and offers little control, which resulted in a sloppy feel for me and warning lights for blistering past 15K. As for other shoes offering a heel strap, I couldn’t feel any difference whether I adjusted it loosely or at maximal tightness. More bothersome was the sole design, which felt increasingly bulky and uncooperative as I went farther, plus the “rolling” effect I felt probably because of the up-curve around the heel block.


Analysis
With today’s offering in the minimal segment, I can’t see what SKORA brings to the table with the Base. The overall design is similar to many others, plus the shoe is heavier and higher than its rivals. The control over the tightness is very limited and the x-strap didn’t work well for me. On the upside, the fabric section at the heel, under the strap, is a great idea and adds to the shoe’s flexibility.


Conclusion
At a price point of $110, and with little to offer in terms of innovation, the Base would not be a top choice for me.


High points 

• Quite unique in terms of looks

Low points

• At 7.9oz, not a lightweight
• 13mm sole (9 without the insole) is thick for a minimal shoe
• X-shaped strap offers little control
• Sole design is questionable

The equipment for this personal review was supplied by SKORA Running free of charge, without any conditions.

Review : VIVOBAREFOOT Neo Trail

Important
Before transitioning to minimalist (or “barefoot”) footwear, make sure you understand what the whole concept entails. Here’s an intro text if you need it.

• Type : Barefoot / Minimal
• Use : Trail Running
• Price : About $140 (unverified)
  
  
  
  

Introduction
There have been so many new products in the minimal / barefoot market recently, I find it hard to even keep track. It’s a blessing, on one side; because a wider choice is often a good thing (provided the offered products are well-conceived). On the other hand, there seems to be many crappy, confusing, nonsensical products which have hit the shelves, and they are not bringing anything of interest to the table (The Fila Skeletoe is just one example of the latter).

So when I opened the box to check out the VIVOBAREFOOT Neo Trail, I did it with a healthy dose of scepticism. I had been searching for a viable shoe fit for serious trail running for some time now, and aside from the Merrell Trail glove (reviewed here), which is a sound choice but doesn’t offer enough grip for single-trail conditions and harsh terrain, I had found nothing.

First impression
I usually don’t analyze packaging or marketing, for obvious reasons, but I have to make an exception here. First of all, VIVOBAREFOOT uses recycled materials for some of the shoe’s parts, like the inner lining. Second, the shoes are guaranteed not to be produced in sweatshops, something commendable, which every apparel maker out there should be doing. Finally, your shoes come wrapped not in throw-away plastic or paper, but in individual, washable, reusable bags that work wonders when you have to carry your mud-stained shoes in a backpack.

The shoe
At 8,25 oz, the Neo trail is light but not a featherweight. This didn’t bug me, as the shoe feels tough and ready for action. It is built with a very wide toe box and a fairly flat end, something I think is now the proven way to go for any minimalist shoe. With that said, however, the sizing is a little tricky, as it relies on the European charts and the shoes run about one size short. (For example, I’m typically a size 7.5 and was advised to get a size 42, which was too big and had to be replaced with a size 41).

The lacing on the pair I got was done from the outside in, which I changed for a more straightforward, pull-to-tighten approach. The shoe doesn’t slim down at the arch section like other barefoot shoes do and leaves ample room for up to 7 diagonal rubber lugs on the outsole and a rock plate under the arch. This is where the Neo Trail really expresses itself: it screams trail.

Trail test
I wore the Neo Trails for a full day at the office before trying them out for a run (I’ve learned that trick from blistering experience). Turns out they didn’t need a break-in. Then I wore the shoes for an outside walk, then a light trail run, then a single-trail cross-fit run, and finally a full-fledge mountain trail run.

The Neo Trail delivered beyond my expectations. At first, I thought the aggressive sole pattern would take away some ground feel for sure, but somehow it doesn’t. You will feel as much terrain as you do in a pair of VFF Komodos, but with the proper protection against protruding rocks and other trail hazards. I was amazed to step in deep mud and feel every inch of the experience, while in the meantime being able to run hard in very rocky downhills relying on the excellent protection of the rockplate and rubber studs.

The grip of this shoe is amazing. I was lucky to run one of my tests with a Training Mobs group wearing regular running shoes and trail shoes and my Neo Trails outperformed the former and were definitely on par with the latter, if not better. The low-to-the-ground, zero-drop 6.5mm sole clearly puts you at an advantage while it not only lets your foot twist and turn like it should, but offers aggressive traction even on wet surfaces.

The upper fabric seems to be truly 100% waterproof, as I stepped in puddles of water, mud patches and ran on trails thickly covered in damp leaves and never got my feet wet. This is fantastic for Canadian runners, as we have to face harsh snowy winters and slushy paths. The combined water resistance and traction of the Neo Trail makes it a serious choice for multiple running conditions throughout the seasons, something not a lot of minimal shoes can pretend to offer.

Conclusion
This is one solid trail running shoe, and thus far my choice when it comes to serious single-trail running. With the excellent proprioception of a true minimal shoe and the traction / protection of a standard trail runner, The Neo Trail offers the best of both worlds. I am very impressed with it and will keep using it for many more happy trail miles in the future.

High points

• One of very few serious minimal trail runners
• Sturdy, yet flexible outsole with excellent traction
• Offers plenty of protection on harsh single trails
• Roomy toe box for free movement
• Zero-drop construction with removable insole
• Waterproof

Low points

• Sizing's a little tricky

The equipment for this personal review was supplied by VIVOBAREFOOT, free of charge, without any conditions.